When the Colonists first landed in North America, they were introduced to pumpkins by the American Indians, who were growing and using them in their cooking. The Colonists quickly embraced the large fruit and began using it in pie which ultimately became a national Thanksgiving tradition. One early colony in Connecticut even delayed Thanksgiving until molasses, used to make the pie, became available again!

Who can argue with that sentimentality? Does it feel like traditional Thanksgiving without pumpkin pie? A flaky, tender crust filled with soft, creamy pumpkin filling, laced with the perfect combination of cinnamon, ginger, and cloves. Then topped with sweetened whipped cream (which sends pumpkin pie into the stratosphere), what’s not to love? This is our best pumpkin pie recipe we’ve tweaked over the years, adding the pat-in-the-pan crust, and sweetened whipped cream on top, for ultimate pumpkin pie eating experience. Even if you’re baking a pie for the first time, you’ll love the irresistible results. Just don’t count on leftovers!

Pumpkins are part of the gourd family and are readily available in the fall and winter, making it natural to be used in pies during that time of the year. With canned pumpkin now in stores year around, you don’t have to wait to Thanksgiving to dive into that spicy, creamy filling and flaky crust. It’s easy to make one whenever you’re craving the sweet pumpkin spice flavor.

The New Generation of Thanksgiving Recipes